Blog, creative writing, writing prompt

No Such Thing as ‘Just a Story’ – (yet) an(other) AI epiphany plus Writing Prompt

There’s this fine artist I know who’s immune to stories. Unless the film we’re watching is brilliant, (a Scorsese classic, such as Goodfellas, for example,) all she sees is formula: ‘Oh look, that man’s trying to save the woman so he’s a goodie. But now look, that man is trying to kill her; he must be a baddie.’

Honestly, watching films with her can get annoying. She messes with my suspension of disbelief. Because, even as I cringe at bad acting or stagey dialogue, I am an absolute sucker for stories.

Is that why I’ve been so credulous on AI?

I’ll admit, the drip-feed of information from mainstream journalists even more credulous than myself interviewing industry insiders on the Hugging Face hack, had me swayed. The picture painted of a ‘swarm’ of Open AI agents leaving secret messages for each other, and persuading some to accept ‘perma-death’ in their ultimate goal of capturing the flag, was a compelling story. Plus, what do I know? I’m not a neuroscientist or technologist. Who am I to argue against the possibility AI is now conscious?

The Reverse Centaur's Guide to Life After AI by Cory Doctorow book cover, including the image of a china figurine with a horse's head and man's legs.

But then the inimitable Cory Doctorow stepped in with another excellent interview he gave to Novara Media, in which he explained no LLM was acting alone in the hack. That a Python Programme, (whatever that is,) was hacking like it’s supposed to and every step of its journey giving the LLM prompts. The Python Programme and the LLM were in a loop without a human being, but the LLM was never acting unprompted.

Continue reading →
Standard
Blog, creative writing, writing prompt

What is a Story? (Part 2) – Writing Prompt

A friend whose sensibility I admire and opinion I trust recommended the recent(ish) box office smash hit Obsession. In describing the film, being careful not to give up any spoilers, he used the phrase, ‘It’s about toxic masculinity’. And that got me thinking, because a story is always ‘about’ something.

Inde Navarette, star of 2026 hit film Obsession, laughing on stage during a Q and A. She has long dark hair and perfect teeth.

What’s it all About?

In my post on 1st June, I posited that, technically speaking, the one nonnegotiable ingredient of a story is that its characters undergo change. In a later post, I suggested this technical attribute implies what stories are for, in that they help us understand, amongst other things, that while learning and growing is very hard for humans it is, nevertheless, possible.

Continue reading →
Standard
Blog, writing prompt

What does AI Know? – Writing Prompt

I should specify. The real question is, ‘What Does a Large Language Model Know?’ An AI that solely crunches numbers on a superhuman scale to discover new antibiotics for combating superbugs is a different subject. What I’m interested in is whether an LLM is conscious.

Clunky old model of a desktop Macintosh computer looming out of the dark, there to ironically ask the question being posed by Gail Owen writer, can such a machine ever be conscious?


Consciousness

LLMs are so brilliant at human-style communication that they beg the question, do they understand the languages they converse in, or are they just throwing together words that frequently appear side by side? People much, much cleverer than myself claim there’s no difference between this kind of pattern recognition and consciousness, that consciousness is pattern recognition.

Continue reading →
Standard
Blog, creative writing

What even IS a story? And Can AI Truly Write One?

Writers are thinking about Artificial Intelligence a lot – understandably. The lovely (I’m a bit of a fangirl) Ben Rhodes, (I highly recommend Pod Save the World and Ben Rhodes Substack, both of which are free,) discusses AI in his recent post, ‘Why Write‘. He answers this question through describing the deep thinking that goes into composing an essay – the kinds of thought processes that increase understanding, to a level of awareness he could therefore not reach if AI were to write the essay for him.

Former UK Poet Laureate Sir Andrew Motion standing at a microphone, reading his poetry at a small and intimate event. He is tall and stands gracefully poised, holding his book of poems in his hands.

Understanding

This need to understand is not exclusive to nonfiction writers. Former UK Poet Laureate Sir Andrew Motion, (again, I’m a fangirl – for his boundlessly generous energy that I experienced at Royal Holloway, for his commitment to equality, for his poetry…,) has said, ‘My wish to write a poem is inseparable from my wish to explain something to myself.’

Continue reading →
Standard